An unsettling and bittersweet novel, Never Let Me Go could be categorised as science fiction because of its central concept. Indeed, I studied it for a science fiction module at university (even giving it an unlikely partner, William Gibson’s Neuromancer, for one of my essays). Like all the best science fiction, it questions our definitions of humanity. It was shortlisted for the Arthur C Clarke Award. Yet it reads more like literary fiction with a focus on nostalgia, friendships and the nature of memory. I last read it before the film was released. I found that this time around, the film was playing in my head and I couldn’t really separate it from the book.
Set in an alternative 1990s, the story is narrated by Kathy H. She lives at a wonderful school, Hailsham, where the students are encouraged to be creative and healthy. The other main characters are her best friend Ruth and the misfit Tommy. The story develops slowly, as Kathy looks back on the complex relationships they had at school and examines the reliability of her memories. However, the students’ privileged situation hides the dystopian nature of the society they are going to serve. I should mention that I didn’t know the big ‘spoiler’ before reading this book, so it was genuinely shocking for me the first time I read it.
The writing style is probably what I like the least about this book. There’s a lack of drama, a meandering way of describing events. Of course, this reflects Kathy’s memories, which she is reconstructing to tell the stories of herself, Ruth and Tommy. I also think there are too many incidental characters who add nothing to the story. I do find the book compelling but I’m not sure I like it. The 2010 film is one of my favourites, which I think shows that the concept is brilliant but that it all depends on the storytelling.
First published in 2005. Shortlisted for that year’s Man Booker Prize.
Unsettling and bittersweet is the perfect description for this book. I didn’t know what the spoiler was either and was surprised by the reveal. Looking forward to your review of the movie, which I haven’t seen.
It’s one of those books which really makes you think. Although it’s not a favourite of mine, I might re-read it again in the future. The film is very worthwhile to watch if you get the chance.
I really enjoyed this back when I read it, but I’ve wondered how it would hold up to a reread given how vital the big reveal is. I also haven’t seen the film, so I should check that out!
Oh yes do check the film out! It’s so well done. I’m glad you enjoyed the book, maybe a re read would be interesting, if re-reading is something you do 🙂
I have neither read the book nor saw the film but have heard of the book for sure. Browsed it and didn’t find myself drawn to it. I MIGHT read this one day though! I’m curious about the unexpected reveal 🙂 Great review, NS!
You might get on better with the film than the book, it’s so sad though.
Fab review! I have a copy of this but I know what happens so I’ve not read it. I’d like to see the film even though I’m not that keen on Keira Knightley! 😂
Thanks! Yes the film is definitely worth watching. I’m not really a Keira fan either but she is very good in this. I like Carey Mulligan though.
That’s really good to know thanks! 🙂
Ah, this is a favourite of mine, but I tend to enjoy these slow, melancholic stories which many authors with Japanese background for some reason seem to master very well. Sorry, it didn’t quite work for you.
I did like the concept but I didn’t get on with the style so well. I’ve read The Remains of the Day and Nocturnes, it’s likely I’ll read another of his. I’m glad it is a favourite of yours though 🙂
Yeah this was shocking the first time I read it too! Great review!
Thanks! 🙂